Metal Roof vs. Shingle Roof Considerations

If it’s time to replace your roof, your first consideration might be: which material should I go with? This isn’t always an easy decision. There are many benefits to both metal roofs and asphalt shingle roofs, so you’ll need to do some homework before you hire a roofer in Virginia to get the job done. In fact, make your roofing contractor part of your decision!

Here at NVB Contracting, part of our services includes metal roof vs. shingle roof consulting, which can be very helpful if you’re on the fence. In the meantime, read this guide on metal roof vs. shingle roof considerations.

Metal Roofing: Pros, Cons and Characteristics

A more complex option than asphalt shingles, metal requires specific techniques, more experienced installers, and more components to ensure a successful installation. Metal roofing is an ideal option for homeowners in Virginia, West Virginia, and Maryland because it is able to resist extreme weather conditions and lasts much longer than asphalt shingles. When well cared for, metal roofs can last up to 50 years or beyond.

Pros of Metal Roofing

Metal roofing brings many benefits to the table, including:

Lightweight – You wouldn’t think metal is lightweight, but it actually is. In fact, it’s lighter than asphalt. This makes the installation job easier on contractors, not to mention the transport process. Also, metal doesn’t put unnecessary stress on a home, which reduces the potential for frame damage.

Fire Resistance – Non-combustible in nature, metal roofing is Class A fire-rated.

Longevity – Metal roofing enjoys a long lifespan — 50+ years when you treat it right. Metal types like copper and zinc can actually last up to 100 years.

Low Long-Term Cost – Yes, you’ll spend more on metal roofing in the beginning, but because it lasts much longer than asphalt, you will save money over the long term. Did you know one metal roof can outlast three asphalt shingle roofs?

Weather Performance – The strongest and most durable roofing material around, metal is great at withstanding extreme weather conditions, such as hail, strong wind, driving rain, ice, snow, heat, and cold.

Environmentally Friendly – Metal happens to be highly recyclable so it’s a good eco-friendly choice.

Energy Efficiency – A metal roof is a cool roof. This means it can absorb heat in higher temperatures while keeping in heat when it’s cold out.

Increased Property Value – Your property value increases with metal roofing, which means you get more bang for your buck.

Low Maintenance – Metal roofs don’t need a lot of maintenance. General upkeep such as removing debris like leaves and branches is all you have to do.

Color Availability – Metal roofs come in a variety of color and style options.

Cons of Metal Roofing

Higher Initial Cost – As said above, metal roofing is more expensive to install initially because the materials and labor cost more.

Limited Qualified Contractors – It’s harder to find a qualified contractor who is experienced in metal roof installation. Shingle installers are much easier to locate.

More Labor Intensive – Metal roofing takes more precise installation than do shingles – the main reason why a trained craftsperson is required. To that end, installation takes more time.

Appearance – Metal can have more of an industrial look than asphalt.

Shingle Roofing: Pros, Cons and Characteristics

Shingle roofs happen to be the most popular and common type in the United States, especially in this area. This is mostly due to their affordability and material availability.

Pros of Shingle Roofing

Economical Over Short Term – Upfront, shingle roofs are cheaper than metal roofs, yet they do not last as long as metal (20 years for shingle vs. 50+ for metal).

Less Expensive Repairs – You’ll spend less on repairs or replacements because shingles are easier and less expensive to fix.

Easy Installation and Replacement – Shingles are less labor and time intensive, which results in a quicker and easier project.

More Qualified Installers – You will have an easier time finding a qualified shingle roof installer.

Cons of Shingle Roofing

Short Lifecycle – Most shingle roofs last up to 25 years max.

Heavier – Asphalt shingles are heavier than metal, adding stress to the structure of a home.

Holds Heat – Due to their dark colors, asphalt shingles attract and absorb heat. As a result, your HVCAC system may have to work overtime to keep you comfortable inside your home.

Color Limitations – Yes, you can choose from a variety of colors or shades for shingles, but metal has a more extensive selection.

Fire Concerns – Yes, shingles are Class A fire-rated, but they are comprised of asphalt. The granules on top of the shingles add the fire-resistance, so the roof could catch fire if a flame were to spark.

Flaking Granules – The granules tend to shed over time, accumulating in your gutters, where they will clog. Plus, as those granules shed, the shingle becomes less and less effective.

Book Your Consultation For Metal vs. Asphalt Roof Replacement

Still not sure which material to go with? Here at NVB Contracting, we offer comprehensive roofing services throughout Virginia, West Virginia, and Maryland, including metal roof vs. shingle roof consulting. If you’re unsure which material to go with, contact us today to book your free consultation.