
12 signs you need a new roof, and 4 that only need a repair
You likely need a new roof if shingles are curling, cracking or bald across multiple slopes, the roof is over 20 years old, decking is sagging, or you have widespread leaks. You probably only need a repair if the problem is a single leak, a pipe boot, a flashing joint or a few missing shingles. About four in ten NVB inspections end with a repair, not a replacement.
12 signs it is time to replace
- 1. Age. 3-tab shingles past 18 years, architectural past 25.
- 2. Curling or cupping across a whole slope, not just a few shingles.
- 3. Bald spots and granule loss. Shiny, dark patches where the asphalt is exposed.
- 4. Cracked or brittle shingles that snap when lifted.
- 5. Granules piling up at downspout outlets after every rain.
- 6. Sagging roof deck. A dip visible from the street means rotted decking or structural trouble.
- 7. Daylight in the attic. If you can see light through the boards, water gets through too.
- 8. Multiple leaks in different rooms, or a leak that comes back after repair.
- 9. Widespread hail bruising confirmed by test-square counts.
- 10. Two existing layers. Code forbids a third; the next roof is a tear-off.
- 11. Missing shingles after every wind event, a sign the seals have failed roof-wide.
- 12. Neighbors' roofs being replaced. Same builder, same year, same shingles, same lifespan.
4 signs that usually mean a repair
- A single leak traced to a pipe boot, a nail pop or a flashing joint. Pipe boots crack after 8 to 12 years and are a $350 fix.
- Chimney or wall flashing that was caulked instead of woven. Re-flashing is a half-day repair.
- A few missing or damaged shingles after a storm on an otherwise sound roof under 15 years old.
- Moss or algae streaks on a roof with plenty of life left. Cleaning and zinc strips solve it.
Repair or replace: the math
A repair makes sense when it costs less than about 20 percent of a replacement and the roof has at least five years of life left. Spending $2,500 patching a 24-year-old 3-tab roof is money you will not get back. Spending $400 on a pipe boot for a 12-year-old architectural roof is an easy call. NVB tells you which side of the line you are on, in writing, after a free inspection. Our roof repair page has a 60-second self-check.
What an inspection actually covers
A HAAG-certified NVB inspector checks every slope, all penetrations and flashing, the ridge and ventilation, the gutters and downspouts, and the attic for moisture, daylight and ventilation. You receive a photo report with a plain recommendation: no action, repair, or replace. There is no charge and no obligation. Schedule it here.
Get a straight answer for your roof
A HAAG-certified NVB inspector photographs every slope and tells you plainly whether you need a repair, a replacement or nothing at all. Free, written, no pressure.
Book a free inspectionSources and further reading
Related questions
Straight answers from 15 years and 6,000+ claims. Still have one? Ask us directly.
Should I repair or replace my roof?
Repair when the problem is isolated (one leak, a pipe boot, a flashing joint) and the roof has five or more years of life left. Replace when damage or wear is roof-wide, the roof is past its rated life, or it already has two layers.
How much does a roof repair cost?
Most repairs run $350 to $1,500 in Northern Virginia. Pipe boots, nail pops and sealant are at the low end; chimney re-flashing and decking replacement are at the high end.
Do I need a new roof if it is 20 years old?
Not automatically. A 20-year-old architectural roof with good ventilation may have 5 to 10 years left. A 20-year-old 3-tab roof is almost always due. An inspection settles it.
Your roof, inspected free. This week.
A HAAG-certified inspector, a written photo report, and a plain answer: repair, replace, or leave it alone. No obligation, ever.
